I tied up a few of an old Crayfish pattern that I always considered a decent Smallmouth or Carp pattern until Saturday evening. I was fishing a pond for the first time with some really good Largemouths and Bluegills in it. I was throwing a lot of stuff (gurglers, wooly buggers, clousers, deceivers) at the bass and getting all kinds of looks but no takes. As I was digging into the bottom of my WW box this old crayfish pattern surfaced (I had even forgot that it was in there). I tied one on and on the first cast a 16" LMB inhaled it. I caught seven Largemouths and about 15 "butt kicking" bluegills - some pushing 10" with the majority of the fish being caught on this pattern before nightfall. Well, obviously the fly that I was using was totally demolished by the time that darkness fell over the pond so I had to head back to the vise.
I spruced this pattern up a bit from my original by adding some mono eyes that I made by melting the ends of some 40 lb. test Maxima Chameleon in brown and coloring the ends with a black sharpie marker. I also reinforced my hackle with very fine copper wire because once my fly was abused and the hackle got pulled back over the claws (fox squirrell tail hair) it pulled the claws all together and the pattern became less productive, not to mention that the rubber legs used foe the antennae were totally gone.