VC regular wrote: You know of all the times I have fished Valley, I do not think I have ever fished a scud pattern specificially. I guess though that some of the subsurface patterns I have fished tend to look like scuds.
I use a Hares ear successfully at Valley, and everywhere else for that matter. I tie it on a scud hook with no wingcase. No one really knows what the fish think, but it looks to me a lot like a scud, mayfly nymph, caddis pupa, or a small stonefly nymph. I believe that's why it works so well. It doesn't look exactly like anything, but suggests a lot of different things that trout like to eat.
VC, I know you know this, (your name in Valley Creek Regular!)but make no mistake about it, turn over a few rocks and you will find scuds at Valley.