Gosh. I can't believe how long this thread has continued - and without degenerating into a slugfest. I'm new to this board, though, maybe you guys don't do slugfests.
I almost feel guilty for having taken the evening off to fish
I saw sulphurs too, but only a couple and the fish weren't rising to them. In fact, they weren't rising to anything (#@#!@#!) and I was doing well on BWO's just yesterday...
Here's how I defend voluntary CR to non fisher people:
1. Practice. I might need to live on this someday.
2. Education - for the trout. I agree with salvelinusfontinalis. I never, ever kill wild native brookies. There aren't enough of them. There will never again be enough of them. But, if I find myself in a place where they are big enough to fish for I will fish for them to try to teach them not to be so damn stupid (I won't mention the times they've made me look stupid).
Here's how I do it: I kiss them on the lips and release them with the instructions to go and sin no more. It's cruel and unusual I know, but if that doesn't educate them I don't know what will.
3. It's fun. I feel no need to justify that. But if I had to I would say it does no real damage, it teaches me about the world I live in and makes me want to take care of it, and it involves me in a community of people who are passionate conservationists. What could be better than that?
But I still like to eat a couple browns now and then, and the wild ones are SO much better