I haven't been spending much time on the fishing forum, so this is the first I noticed this thread. I apologize for the late contribution.
I already pay to play. It's called a fishing license and in my case, it's a non-resident license meaning a lot more than most of you. I also purchase a trout and a lake Erie stamp, which covers what most of you are talking about. IMO, we don't need anymore stinkin stamps.;-)
Seriously, I would not buy a special access stamp beyond what we are already paying. HOWEVER, if they chose to raise the cost of the trout stamp, I'd likely continue buying that. And keep in mind, I haven't fished for trout at all this year... yet. So it is a donation. You are welcome.
I noticed at least one other person stating that they are against any special access tag and that it should be open to everyone who buys the proper license. Add me to that list.
Mike, I read your post about donating to a cause that was purchasing game lands, even though you don't hunt. I can certainly understand that. I was a member of Ducks Unlimited for several years, even though I never hunted waterfowl in my live. Why would I do this? There is no other group that does more for wetlands, and preserving those helps everyone, including trout anglers. Wetlands recharge the ground water, even when there is no constant outflow.
Anyway, that is my two cents. We don't need any more tags or stamps.