Had to make Lemonade ..... out of the Lemons that I brought

MJMFlyfisher

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 7, 2023
Messages
173
City
Schuylkill Co.
Played a little hooky from work on Friday afternoon...... Shhhhh. I needed to shake off the winter cold and windy blues, and the weather was beautiful!
I figured I'd go play with some of the fresh stockies on a delayed harvest water and some junk flies to feel a little tug on the line.
I made the decision to leave my Richardson chest box at home......after all I won't be needing any of the hatch matching anything in there right?? LOL

Started out as planned and landed 6-8 cookie cutter stockie rainbows on a fly that shall remain nameless, but rhymes with Kermy Germy. 😉 (I still feel a little dirty)

I started noticing a few bugs fluttering by.....bigger bugs.......?? and then I saw a slashy rise. And another.
I didn't think about stoneflies!!

oh-nooo-facepalm-baby.gif


And here they were bopping around all over the place. I looked downstream of where I was standing and could see fish after fish rising strongly in the glide below the next riffle.
I contemplated the 30 min drive back to my house for my fly box and back but figured I might miss the action by the time I got back.
I seriously didn't have a single dry fly on me. Except my midge box which wasn't gonna help.

🤔 Hmmmmmmm.......
Maybe I could get below them and try to nymph them up one at a time? , but what fun would that be??

Time to make the lemonade. LOL

In addition to the junk flies and streamers I had, I also had one small box of attractor style nymphs , some beadheads, prince nymphs, and a row of some unweighted partridge/ hares ears in a size 12. Partridge legs, pheasant tail, gold tinsel, orange thread......you know, a perfect match for an early stonefly!
That was the closest thing I had to size and might actually float.
So I stripped off the junk flies, put a fresh length of 5X tippet on , treated the nymph with some floatant and greased the leader and tippet.

I slid above the first fish on an angle 45 degrees down to it.......Figured at the very least I could skitter and hop the nymph on the surface like these stoneflies and maybe trick one that way if he couldn't get a good enough look at it.
Made a little slackline cast down to the first fish and he didn't even hesitate! GULP.
It was a bit of a challenge getting it to float after each fish , but 14 trout later I managed to successfully fish the nicest stonefly hatch that I can remember having with a stupid floating hares ear with an orange head!
Even some wild browns mixed in with the stockies.
And it seemed like the more mangled the fly got it worked just as well or better so I just kept floating it.

The killer was letting it float dead drift and then hopping and skittering it straight back upstream and let if fall back again into a feeding lane.
I gotta admit, I was feeling pretty spiffy after that one! 😁

(And of course I immediately put my chest box back into my travel bin as soon as I got home. Not doing that again!)

Any other "Lemonade" stories??

stone1.jpg

Stone2.jpg

And the mangled "Stonefly dry"
Stone3.jpg
 
Last edited:
Played a little hooky from work on Friday afternoon...... Shhhhh. I needed to shake off the winter cold and windy blues, and the weather was beautiful!
I figured I'd go play with some of the fresh stockies on a delayed harvest water and some junk flies to feel a little tug on the line.
I made the decision to leave my Richardson chest box at home......after all I won't be needing any of the hatch matching anything in there right?? LOL

Started out as planned and landed 6-8 cookie cutter stockie rainbows on a fly that shall remain nameless, but rhymes with Kermy Germy. 😉 (I still feel a little dirty)

I started noticing a few bugs fluttering by.....bigger bugs.......?? and then I saw a slashy rise. And another.
I didn't think about stoneflies!!

View attachment 1641240705

And here they were bopping around all over the place. I looked downstream of where I was standing and could see fish after fish rising strongly in the glide below the next riffle.
I contemplated the 30 min drive back to my house for my fly box and back but figured I might miss the action by the time I got back.
I seriously didn't have a single dry fly on me. Except my midge box which wasn't gonna help.

🤔 Hmmmmmmm.......
Maybe I could get below them and try to nymph them up one at a time? , but what fun would that be??

Time to make the lemonade. LOL

In addition to the junk flies and streamers I had, I also had one small box of attractor style nymphs , some beadheads, prince nymphs, and a row of some unweighted partridge/ hares ears in a size 12. Partridge legs, pheasant tail, gold tinsel, orange thread......you know, a perfect match for an early stonefly!
That was the closest thing I had to size and might actually float.
So I stripped off the junk flies, put a fresh length of 5X tippet on , treated the nymph with some floatant and greased the leader and tippet.

I slid above the first fish on an angle 45 degrees down to it.......Figured at the very least I could skitter and hop the nymph on the surface like these stoneflies and maybe trick one that way if he couldn't get a good enough look at it.
Made a little slackline cast down to the first fish and he didn't even hesitate! GULP.
It was a bit of a challenge getting it to float after each fish , but 14 trout later I managed to successfully fish the nicest stonefly hatch that I can remember having with a stupid floating hares ear with an orange head!
Even some wild browns mixed in with the stockies.
And it seemed like the more mangled the fly got it worked just as well or better so I just kept floating it.

The killer was letting it float dead drift and then hopping and skittering it straight back upstream and let if fall back again into a feeding lane.
I gotta admit, I was feeling pretty spiffy after that one! 😁

(And of course I immediately put my chest box back into my travel bin as soon as I got home. Not doing that again!)

Any other "Lemonade" stories??

View attachment 1641240702
View attachment 1641240703
And the mangled "Stonefly dry"
View attachment 1641240704
Irony is all the guys throwing around their stonefly imitations!
 
For some reason, I always enjoy adapting and overcoming the dumb obstacles I seem to constantly present myself as it has become part of the experience. I sometimes opt to fish with a spin rod that was my first real fishing rod and boy has it seen it all. Mostly I fish streamers on it now as I am a weird fella but one time I was fishing this small bass pond and catching lunker after lunker until my crappy bail cracked open and line would get stuck in it. With the sun going down, all that I could do was handline for the rest of the night and pulling in 3-pound bass handlining spinners was quite the experience.
 
stoneflies swim to a rock and crawl onto it to hatch, not in the middle of the water like a mayfly. using a partridge and hare like that on a greased line looked like the actual insects caught in the current trying to get to shore.
 
stoneflies swim to a rock and crawl onto it to hatch, not in the middle of the water like a mayfly. using a partridge and hare like that on a greased line looked like the actual insects caught in the current trying to get to shore.
I think what it actually was, was the adults coming back to lay eggs. They were fluttering and hitting the water , riding a bit, hoping around, flying off etc.
They were really active on the surface and the trout were waiting for them! 👍
 
I think what it actually was, was the adults coming back to lay eggs. They were fluttering and hitting the water , riding a bit, hoping around, flying off etc.
They were really active on the surface and the trout were waiting for them! 👍

It's times like those when skating a palmered hackled Elk Wing Caddis appropriately colored & sized to match a Little Black Stonefly can be deadly...
 
It's times like those when skating a palmered hackled Elk Wing Caddis appropriately colored & sized to match a Little Black Stonefly can be deadly...
Of if I only had my dry fly box, that was my exact thought.....it would have been much easier! LOL But it was still fun.
Same result just got there a little differently. 😁
 
Totally OT because it is related to preparedness...

However, I tie a version of a female Hendrickson designed specifically to fish during ovipositing.

It is an appropriately sized and colored dry fly with an upright poly wing tied in at the center of the hook shank that is fully and heavily palmered with hackle 1.2 times the hook gape.

When the females are ovipositing, I'll stand upstream of the riffles they prefer, grease my leader and cast downstream. When the fly is in position, I hold my rod way up so the fly just bounces off the tops of the riffles. If the fish don't clobber it bouncing, I abruptly skate it a foot or so upstream and let it drift back down again.

I've caught as many as 40 fish on some Pocono streams employing this fly & tactic in the short window of opportunity in late afternoon & early evening when the naturals are doing their thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kms
Totally OT because it is related to preparedness...

However, I tie a version of a female Hendrickson designed specifically to fish during ovipositing.

It is an appropriately sized and colored dry fly with an upright poly wing tied in at the center of the hook shank that is fully and heavily palmered with hackle 1.2 times the hook gape.

When the females are ovipositing, I'll stand upstream of the riffles they prefer, grease my leader and cast downstream. When the fly is in position, I holdmy rod way up so the fly just bounces off the tops of the riffles. If the fish don't clobber it bouncing, I abruptly skate it a foot or so upstream and let it drift back down again.

I've caught as many as 40 fish on some Pocono streams employing this fly & tactic in the short window of opportunity in late afternoon & early evening when the naturals are doing their thing.
I have something similar in the quiver as well for the same purpose! 😁
1000001984.jpg
 
Nice!

I used to tie in an egg, but quickly came to conclusion it didn't make much difference to the fish and just soaked up water when skated.

These days if I feel an egg is necessary for a fussy fish or my own ego, I'll apply a small blob of yellow Orvis Strike Putty to the hook shank at the back of the abdomen.
 
Top