Death by Fly Fishing (almost) #1

Tabasco-Joe

Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2022
Messages
39
City
SEPA
Since its mid-February and a good time for story telling I finally sat down and put a few of my more notable winter fishing experiences to paper.

Here is my first. More to follow.
The good news about fishing in the winter is there is no worry about snakes. At some point I'll write a series about my snake/fishing encounters.

My family is from Union County (PA). Although I grew up in Allentown I spent most summers, holidays, and vacations in Union County. After my parents retired, they moved back to Mifflinburg. So, I spent many days fishing, hunting, exploring the state land in the area. I am a seasoned outdoorsman and am completely at home in the forest under almost any conditions.

Since it’s now February and one of my favorite times to fish, I thought I’d share a few experiences I’ve had winter fly fishing. This one occurred in about 2008. My father had passed, and my mother was undergoing treatment for breast cancer. My work situation allowed me to work from her house while taking her in for treatments and doing a lot of house work she couldn’t due because of fatigue. The treatments and after recovery ran about six months. I was able to arrange my workday so I could get my work done and fish most afternoons. Mifflinburg allows quick access to several nice trout streams including Penns, White Deer, Buffalo Creek, etc.

One outing in mid-February was memorable for a near disaster on the water. The temperatures in town were around freezing and snow was expected to start around noon. With temperatures dropping. Perfect. No one on Penns. It should be a great day. The trusty RAM was outfitted with a lot of safety equipment, so I headed out to the lower end of Penns. As I parked by the Cherry Run parking spot a light snow started. I moved into the run just below the start of the special regs section and noticed a few rising fish. I couldn’t see any hatch, so I tied on my usual go to for Penns in the situation, a size 18 BWO emerger. My pattern was a simple wood duck tail, dark olive Super Fine body, and a tuft of natural CDC as a wing. I had a hard time spotting the fly and detecting strikes in the snowfall but did land a few small browns.

I decided to get a little more adventurous and struck out for one of my favorite spots on Penns, the terminus of Old Mingle Tail. This spot has a deep channel next to the parking spot and must be forded to get to the best fishing spots. I carefully got into the water and crossed. The stream was waist deep with a swift current but crossable with great care. I moved upstream fishing nymphs and streamers. I measured the water temp in the mid-30s and the air temp was now down to 25. I was fighting ice build up on the line but still managed to land a few 8-9” browns. I think a chub or two as well. By now it was snowing harder with an inch or so accumulated on the ground. I figured I should start heading out before it gets too deep. On my way back across I lost my footing and was completely dunked. Chest waders are now full of freezing water. It was only about 25 yards to the truck but by the time I got there I was already shivering uncontrollably. The truck had a cap with Yakima bar racks which I usually use to hold the rod while I change gear. I put the rod on the bars, quickly stripped down to my underwear, threw the wet gear in the back, and jumped in the truck turning up the heat to the max. I had a thermos of hot coffee and after about ten minutes drank a few cups. It took about a half hour to get back to normal. When I’m traveling I usually keep a duffle bag of spare cloths in the back seat and this time they really came in handy. I got dressed and decided I had enough excitement and started to head home. By this time there was about three inches of snow on the ground. I went up Old Mingle Road and then up Cherry Run Road heading to Bear Run Road and Rt 45 to get back to Mifflinburg. About the time I got to Bear Run Road I realized I had placed the rod on the roof. And, you guessed it, it was not there. I retraced my path all the way back to Penns but couldn’t find the rod. It was an Orvis with a nice Ross reel. The only rod I brought up to my mothers. Well now I was pissed. Mulling this over on my way back out to 45 I decided there was enough time to get up the Flyfisher’s Paradise and see it Steve had any rods in stock.

I arrived about half an hour before closing but he rigged up a couple of rods he had left and let me cast them in front of the store. He gave me good discount on a two piece Sage he was having a hard time selling and it became one of my favorite rods.

Sometimes GOD looks out for fools. Especially if they are fishermen.

And to anyone who found the rod, it's yours.
 
Glad you came out of this safely - although minus a rod.

Another good reason to not fish this time of year IMO
As you will see in my next stories, I have pushed the edge of my limitations and come out unscathed.
Not that I recommend others do so.
I'm 70 now with a few medical issues so no longer as adventurous.
There are places to fish in the winter that are perfectly safe.
One example might be fishing the Little Lehigh from the bank in the fly section.
 
I always worry when I see cars parked by our place in the winter for the reason you described.

I am upset that DCNR closed vehicle access on Old Mingle Road. That was one of my favorite spots to take a jeep ride and picnic and swim in the summer.
 
Since its mid-February and a good time for story telling I finally sat down and put a few of my more notable winter fishing experiences to paper.

Here is my first. More to follow.
The good news about fishing in the winter is there is no worry about snakes. At some point I'll write a series about my snake/fishing encounters.

My family is from Union County (PA). Although I grew up in Allentown I spent most summers, holidays, and vacations in Union County. After my parents retired, they moved back to Mifflinburg. So, I spent many days fishing, hunting, exploring the state land in the area. I am a seasoned outdoorsman and am completely at home in the forest under almost any conditions.

Since it’s now February and one of my favorite times to fish, I thought I’d share a few experiences I’ve had winter fly fishing. This one occurred in about 2008. My father had passed, and my mother was undergoing treatment for breast cancer. My work situation allowed me to work from her house while taking her in for treatments and doing a lot of house work she couldn’t due because of fatigue. The treatments and after recovery ran about six months. I was able to arrange my workday so I could get my work done and fish most afternoons. Mifflinburg allows quick access to several nice trout streams including Penns, White Deer, Buffalo Creek, etc.

One outing in mid-February was memorable for a near disaster on the water. The temperatures in town were around freezing and snow was expected to start around noon. With temperatures dropping. Perfect. No one on Penns. It should be a great day. The trusty RAM was outfitted with a lot of safety equipment, so I headed out to the lower end of Penns. As I parked by the Cherry Run parking spot a light snow started. I moved into the run just below the start of the special regs section and noticed a few rising fish. I couldn’t see any hatch, so I tied on my usual go to for Penns in the situation, a size 18 BWO emerger. My pattern was a simple wood duck tail, dark olive Super Fine body, and a tuft of natural CDC as a wing. I had a hard time spotting the fly and detecting strikes in the snowfall but did land a few small browns.

I decided to get a little more adventurous and struck out for one of my favorite spots on Penns, the terminus of Old Mingle Tail. This spot has a deep channel next to the parking spot and must be forded to get to the best fishing spots. I carefully got into the water and crossed. The stream was waist deep with a swift current but crossable with great care. I moved upstream fishing nymphs and streamers. I measured the water temp in the mid-30s and the air temp was now down to 25. I was fighting ice build up on the line but still managed to land a few 8-9” browns. I think a chub or two as well. By now it was snowing harder with an inch or so accumulated on the ground. I figured I should start heading out before it gets too deep. On my way back across I lost my footing and was completely dunked. Chest waders are now full of freezing water. It was only about 25 yards to the truck but by the time I got there I was already shivering uncontrollably. The truck had a cap with Yakima bar racks which I usually use to hold the rod while I change gear. I put the rod on the bars, quickly stripped down to my underwear, threw the wet gear in the back, and jumped in the truck turning up the heat to the max. I had a thermos of hot coffee and after about ten minutes drank a few cups. It took about a half hour to get back to normal. When I’m traveling I usually keep a duffle bag of spare cloths in the back seat and this time they really came in handy. I got dressed and decided I had enough excitement and started to head home. By this time there was about three inches of snow on the ground. I went up Old Mingle Road and then up Cherry Run Road heading to Bear Run Road and Rt 45 to get back to Mifflinburg. About the time I got to Bear Run Road I realized I had placed the rod on the roof. And, you guessed it, it was not there. I retraced my path all the way back to Penns but couldn’t find the rod. It was an Orvis with a nice Ross reel. The only rod I brought up to my mothers. Well now I was pissed. Mulling this over on my way back out to 45 I decided there was enough time to get up the Flyfisher’s Paradise and see it Steve had any rods in stock.

I arrived about half an hour before closing but he rigged up a couple of rods he had left and let me cast them in front of the store. He gave me good discount on a two piece Sage he was having a hard time selling and it became one of my favorite rods.

Sometimes GOD looks out for fools. Especially if they are fishermen.

And to anyone who found the rod, it's yours.
Safety Third, I always say.
Glad to hear you lived to tell the tale!
 
I always worry when I see cars parked by our place in the winter for the reason you described.

I am upset that DCNR closed vehicle access on Old Mingle Road. That was one of my favorite spots to take a jeep ride and picnic and swim in the summer.
So, you can't drive to the end of old mingle road now?
 
My closest encounter with eternity happened in Lycoming County. My best friend Jeff and I were fishing the canyon section of a well known stream. Once down on this section the only real options are to fish it upstream to the next road crossing or turn around and hike back down to your starting point. It was early May. The winter that year had been especially brutal with lots of snow, ice and wind.

We had driven the road over the canyon and noticed that a strong wind shear had topped a good number of trees along the stream. The damage was obvious because the broken branches were grey.

It was a very warm day with low clouds. The humidity was high. Kind of perfect weather for BWO emergence. I don’t remember how the fishing was, but the deeper into the canyon we got the darker the sky got. As we entered into the section where the trees had been topped the wind started to gust and a squall blew up. The next thing all hell broke loose as 6-10 foot sections of dagger pointed branches began to rain down on us. A couple of smaller branches glanced off our shoulders as we scrambled up the bank to the shelter of the huge old cedars that grow below the road above. Like late spring storms tend to do it was over quickly. I probably don’t remember the fishing because I was so thankful for making it out without major damage.
 
Was fishing the Pine Creek canyon at the delayed harvest area with a few buddies on a bluebird day. A noise started to come upstream and continued to build until we’d have sworn one of the old locomotives was running up the valley on its long-gone tracks. The sun suddenly went away and the sky opened up with some of the heaviest rain we’d ever been in. We scrambled back to our trucks as the monsoon pounded us. Within seconds of reaching our vehicles, the rain moved on and the sun came out. Back in the water, boys! Pine Creek never rose or went off-color… maybe it was the old locomotive.
 
Last edited:
I have had several close calls, but the most notable was when fall turkey hunting 20 or more years ago. I was several miles from anywhere, high on a mountain in "the rocks," had called in a turkey, and had shot it. It began rolling/hopping downhill, and I rose to get a second shot to anchor it. The gun was "off safe," of course. I took several steps, the rocks went out from under me, and I flipped in the air and crashed to the rocks. I had lost hold of my shotgun. When lying there, I saw the gun lying two feet in front of me, pointing directly at my belly. If it had gone off, I would not be typing this. I guess God had other plans for me, though I can't think of anything special I have done during the intervening time.
 
Not me but a friend and his son were fishing by our place and a black bear came off the bank, walked between them and up the other side of the bank. Acted like it didn’t even notice them.
 
Not me but a friend and his son were fishing by our place and a black bear came off the bank, walked between them and up the other side of the bank. Acted like it didn’t even notice them.
Yeah, all of my bear encounters, which are numerous, have been issue free. Each time I've seen one they quickly went in the opposite direction.
One time on Jeans, I had a BIG sow with two cubs run across the creek and pass in front of me at about 10yrds, then they stopped instead of continuing on, which I thought was VERY odd! This gave me time to get my phone out for some really good video.

After filming them for maybe 2 minutes, I see a third cub come across the creek and run right in front of me at 5yrds, no lie, 5yrds, to join it's family. That explained why they stopped when/where they did. Then they all ran off through the woods. It was the most awesome bear encounter I've ever had! They really want nothing to do with humans.

Here are the sow and the cub from the video.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5655.JPEG
    IMG_5655.JPEG
    274.7 KB · Views: 35
  • IMG_5656.JPEG
    IMG_5656.JPEG
    254.9 KB · Views: 35
Last edited:
Anyone else ever have a bear encounter on the water? That scared the **** out of me. Wont be going back there without proper bear defense.
I have. But you have to wait for #4 for that tale.

Up until this summer I owned a cabin at the base of the mountain north of Hartleton.
Many bear around the property including one my son took with a crossbow.
So I'm very accustomed to run-ins with bear.

I used to have a number of game cameras on the property. I have one video of a bear chewing up a camera. You can see his teeth from a few inches.
It got so bad with them attacking my cameras I had to put concertina wire around any tree with a camera.
Still had lots of hair in the razor wire but no more damage cameras.
I also had buck attack cameras.
I believe it was because these were near infrared LEDs and gave off a slight visible glow.
 
Last edited:
Top