not meaning to offend anyone but reading wader threads for the past, IDK 15 years, makes me think people expect too much out of waders.
Agree. Water is a worthy adversary.
I don’t really care if my small stream waders leak a little, which is why I buy beaters for that purpose, and when they get too bad, I just toss them. You’re usually not ever in water above your knees, unless you’re retrieving a stuck fly. And other than maybe from say Thanksgiving to Opening Day, you’re generating enough heat from all the hiking involved to where you don’t get cold, even with a minor leak. I’d say I average about a year of use out of my beater pairs, though the two pairs of Redington’s I had got me at least 2 years. One pair might have made it 3 years. Hoping for the same from the yet unopened $80 pair I got last year.
On big water, especially early and late season, I absolutely do care if my waders leak. You’re moving around less and generating less heat. And standing thigh deep in cold water is way different than standing ankle to knee deep. This is why I keep a pair of nicer Orvis or Bean waders around as a “flagship” pair. (But even those I still try to find on sale or close out, or with a coupon code.) When my nice pair begins to leak enough to make me uncomfortable on bigger water, but not yet catastrophically, they get demoted to the beater ranks to finish out their life.
For me, the barometer is whether I can wring water out of my socks at the end of the day. Once that happens, unless it’s a very isolated acute leak that can be easily patched, I toss them. Aquaseaing all the seams on the waders when they start to go will buy you a little more time, but it’s a PITA, and when you get to that point, the end is near anyway. I used to do that, but just toss them now. Again, waders are a consumable. Like tippet, or tires on cars.