Why do we fish?

I have a hard time saying exactly why I like it so much. It seems like a never ending learning experience I guess. Mostly it is just plain fun. I caught my first trout on a Royal Coachman wet fly from some variety pack of flies I bought at a discount store. I was using my super heavy duty South Bend fly rod with a piece of heavy mono knotted to the fly line. Remember feeding out line beacause I had no idea how to cast. I just got fly out there and twitched it back and it worked. I was 15 and had no one to teach me. I have been hooked ever since.
 
Last edited:
I've heard this before, but it is exactly how I feel. Trout live in beautiful places and I enjoy the adventure in going to those places hoping to catch a few. Even if I don't succeed in catching any I have the surroundings to fall back on and still have an enjoyable time.
I'd say most wild trout do live in beautiful places, but stocked trout, not so much. 😉
 
I'd say most wild trout do live in beautiful places, but stocked trout, not so much. 😉
Lots of stocked trout live in beautiful places. And lots of wild trout live in pretty mediocre/crappy places. And lots of wild trout live in beautiful places. And lots of stocked trout live in mediocre/crappy places.

Lots of great brown trout fisheries in rundown, urban industrial type of settings....
 
Lots of stocked trout live in beautiful places. And lots of wild trout live in pretty mediocre/crappy places. And lots of wild trout live in beautiful places. And lots of stocked trout live in mediocre/crappy places.

Lots of great brown trout fisheries in rundown, urban industrial type of settings....
Very true.

It has to be the actual fishing not just the places or fishing isn't going to stick. I love to fish and catch fish. I have buddies out in the dark in the tidal Skuke (or AC Jetty or Seaside after dark) strapped in case they have visitors at the car when they return to the lot.

In my book, it's got to be the fishing itself if it's going to become a lifelong addiction like it has been for me. And the women, which was sagely mentioned early in the thread.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kms
Lots of stocked trout live in beautiful places.
I left room for that by saying "not so much".
And lots of wild trout live in pretty mediocre/crappy places.
I left room for that too, by saying "most". 😉
One of my best wild browns was caught in a very mediocre place.

Also, Elkhorn Creek in West Virginia, which is a crap hole (literally), has some excellent wild trout fishing! Both browns and rainbows.
 
Last edited:
Lots of stocked trout live in beautiful places. And lots of wild trout live in pretty mediocre/crappy places. And lots of wild trout live in beautiful places. And lots of stocked trout live in mediocre/crappy places.

Lots of great brown trout fisheries in rundown, urban industrial type of settings....
Like alongside an old steel mill? 🙂
 
I hate all this pretentious, esoteric, philosophical BS. Like I said before, I fish 'cause I like it. Doesn't need explained!
Similarly, I fish because I like catching fish (of all types.). Location is secondary; I can get my “wilds experience” and enjoyment of pristine environments from hiking, birding, cross-country skiing, snowshoeing and fishing, so fishing is not a requisite. To put an exclamation point on that, I’ve fished for and caught American shad from the Easton sewage treatment plant discharge plume; I’ve frequently fished for and caught numerous striped bass from the Delaware Estuary in central Philly; I’ve caught 10-12” wild brook trout from a sewage and coal wast laden stream in Schuylkill Co; I’ve fished for and caught muskellunge at the Tully/Schuylkill R confluence in Reading; and I’ve fished for and captured large browns from Logan Branch(😂), Centre Co. in its less than scenic hey-day. Just give me a tug on the line and I’m a happy camper.
 
The Lackawanna River runs along old steel mills, and coal mines
And is very channelized with levees, as it winds through many small towns.
Countless strip malls, and any other kind of business you can think of - along the entire waterway

Most urbanized trout stream I can remember fishing.
But man. the fish are there....
 
Similarly, I fish because I like catching fish (of all types.). Location is secondary...

FWIW - I fished in the Gowanus Canal and Central Park Lake & Pond regularly when I lived in NYC.

I also have a few Tenkara rods, a pack spinning rod & reel and associated tackle for both permanently in the back of my SUV. With this gear, I've fished more than a few ponds I've come across in industrial or municipal parks.

BTW - The ponds in the Greenfield Industrial Park in Lancaster are loaded with fish...

Bottom line, I fish anywhere there are fish.
 
My story might take a different path than others. Like many fisherman I was introduced to the sport at a young age by my father. We fished for crappies, bluegill, walleyes, catfish, SM & LM bass, northern Pike but trout fishing (fly fishing) was the main event. I was 3 sport athlete in HS (football, basketball, and track), participated in college track for awhile. I was always very competitive and, without realizing it at the time, I made the natural transition to allowing fishing and hunting to fill that competitive void.

After entering the workforce, my love of the outdoors consumed my free time. I enjoyed the outdoors so much I was driven to better at it. I wanted to unlock every secret (which is an unrealistic goal but it fueled my fire). I was at peace when I was hunting or fishing. I wanted to get to that next hole or that next ridge. I travelled all around the US. I ended up hunting in 27 states and fished in 12 states. It was a wonderful journey.

I’m retired now (in the last quartile of my life) and I can be in the outdoors any day I want. It a great place to be. My wife is very worldly but her sweet spot is filled by solitary activities like reading, knitting and baking. We are the perfect pair. If I didn’t have a compatible wife I can envision a much different path for me.
 
It's like golf. Beautiful surroundings and you play the last 9 holes in...8 doubles and a birdie. You remember the birdie and keep coming back 🤣
It’s possible to shoot an under par perfect round of golf, but even if every cast is perfect, every float is drag free and every fly in your vest looks exactly like what’s in the air and on the water, the trout may well rise and refuse everything you have to offer.

The cup in the green never refuses a perfect putt.

That’s why I fish and think of golf as a rather mundane pursuit.

The people who play golf are not making the trout streams more crowded, so golf does have its good points.
 
I fish because:

Fishing is one of the few things where I have achieved a level of prowess I find satisfactory. That doesn't mean I'm any good at it. it just means I'm good enough to suit me.

Fishing is my main remaining connection to the man who taught me to fish, my Dad. Even though he has been gone for almost 17 years, he is still my best fishing buddy even though I usually have to carry his side of the conversation as well as my own..

Even though trout of any kind or origin are pretty far down my list of preferences, I fish because I love to eat (most) fish. Right now, I have at least a dozen messes of walleye, perch and crappie in the freezer to hold me through the winter. They are there because I love to fish.

Probably most of all, I fish because being alone on the water is the most serene place I know. It is the only place I can escape having to be on pins and needles worrying that I might not have heard the last thing you said to me. I'm a social enough guy but if you are not there, I don't have to worry about hearing you.

Finally, I fish because I still some day hope to catch a redwing blackbird in my hat and then yell at him the same way he has been yelling at me since I arrived streamside (applies in May and June only).

So, that's why. Best of the Season to all!
 
I’m surprised that no one has posted this up to now, so here goes. I think this pretty well sums up what most of us have said:

Testament of a Fisherman​

I fish because I love to. Because I love the environs where trout are found, which are invariably beautiful, and hate the environs where crowds of people are found, which are invariably ugly. Because of all the television commercials, ****tail parties, and assorted social posturing I thus escape. Because in a world where most men seem to spend their lives doing what they hate, my fishing is at once an endless source of delight and an act of small rebellion. Because trout do not lie or cheat and cannot be bought or bribed, or impressed by power, but respond only to quietude and humility, and endless patience. Because I suspect that men are going this way for the last time and I for one don’t want to waste the trip. Because mercifully there are no telephones on trout waters. Because in the woods I can find solitude without loneliness. … And finally, not because I regard fishing as being so terribly important, but because I suspect that so many of the other concerns of men are equally unimportant and not nearly so much fun.

— Robert Traver, Anatomy of a Fisherman


…and after all these years since Traver penned this it’s still true, with the exception of “there are no telephones on trout waters.”
 
Top