I think that it depends on where you are fishing. Way back in the 1980's I had a roommate who guided on the Delaware River(New Hope, PA- Trenton, NJ) for Striped Bass.
We would go out on the river at dusk and fish with Black Bombers, which were surface plugs that we would rip across the surface. They were at least 10" long. Stripers aren't lure shy. A small striper will nail a plug that size, and burn line off of your spinning reel.
I always had good success with anything on top in black and subsurface in white. I hope that helps you.
I talked to my former roommate several years ago at one of our former roommate's funeral and he told me that when he takes clients out on the river now, he uses the cut shad that he caught during the shad run for the later striper run.