I’ve adjusted my setup down to 4 boxes…Concept behind my setup is my desire to only need to carry one box at a time. Here’s the breakdown of the 4:
1. Gemmie/Small Stream Box (small size) – Attractor dries, a few generic nymphs, a few small streamers. I also have a few bigger night fishing flies in this box, since it’s generally the one I carry while backpacking.
2. Hatch Matcher/Limestone (medium size) – Different life stages of the common PA hatches I run into most often. Sulfurs, MB’s, GD’s, SD’s, and different Caddis make up the majority of it. To a lesser degree, some BWO’s and Quills in there too. Some scuds, sculpins, terrestrials, and other limestoney stuff as when I’m hatch fishing it’s often on a limestoner.
3. Warmwater/Bass (large size) – Bigger streamers, poppers, big nymphs, whiteflys, etc.
4. General Trout (medium size) - Little bit of everything box. Doesn’t have an arsenal of any one fly, but a smattering of everything. Not good if a specific massive hatch comes off as I may only have 2 or 3 of that specific fly in there. I try not to use this one much, but when I don’t know what I’m gonna encounter, or I’m planning on fishing a bunch of different kinds of streams in one day, I carry this one.
Each of the above has a few of the real everyday basics too…Adams/EHC/Buggers/etc. Works for me, and I haven’t really run into a situation where I’ve been wishing I had a different box. Nice to not have a pack full of boxes I’m not using while hiking around too.