I was making fun of the photography often found in mags like the Drake, moreso than print vs. digital.
Don't get me wrong, I understand that HDR can be done quite well. But many of the examples I see are just so fake looking. Oversaturated like an oil painting. And glossy paper makes them look even more fake than matte computer screens.
I appreciate a good oil painting, and a good photograph. I just see them as two different things, conveying totally different feelings. I can't bring myself to appreciate hybrids, it leaves me emotionally confused.
Cue a photographer to explain that HDR doesn't have to be oversaturated. That's without a doubt true, and I've seen a few great ones. But it certainly leads to the tendency to oversaturate.