moon1284 wrote:
Cut the loop, nail knot leader to fly line, and make a knotted tapered leader. That should help. I agree with TB though, a 12' leader will be easier to handle on a heavier wt rod.
Lot of opinions in the thread, which is good. The OP should experiment and see what works best for them, but FWIW, I disagree with this ^. And would recommend some other experimentation first before cutting your welded loop off your fly line, since you can't undo that. Here's why:
I don't think a loop to loop vs. a nail knot makes an appreciable difference here. They both add essentially the same mass to the system, and any mass added would essentially be a wash between them when comparing them. You gotta connect your leader to your fly line somehow right?
Bottom line, all other things being equal, the longer the leader, the harder it is to turn over. Regardless of line weight trying to turn it over. When you're talking about relatively light line weights (2 weight for example) you have less mass in the line to help you turn the leader over. Problem is, most people (including me) when fishing a 2 or 3 weight use a very similar leader setup to what they use on say a 5 weight. So the leader is more or less the same, but in the case of a 2 weight it is being casted by a line with relatively less mass...thus it's relatively harder to turn over and requires more energy/force (in the form of speed in this case since mass has been reduced via the lighter fly line) to do so. Hence the OP feeling like he had to hustle his casts to turn over the longer leaders on his 2 wt.
The solution is to use a lighter leader set up with the lighter line weights, or make the leader shorter, and thus require less energy from the lighter fly lines to turn it over. Good rule of thumb for any type of fishing...Use the shortest possible leader that you need to get the presentation you want. When small stream fishing with my 3 weights (my lightest rods) I don't really ever see the need to have a leader longer than 7.5 feet from fly connection to the end of my tippet. If I’m on a bigger stream and need a longer leader to get the presentation I want, a longer 5 or 6 weight is a better tool for the job anyway.