As a surf fisherman, I have used Glacier Gloves for a while now. I also own the fingerless Orvis for winter trout fishing. Both work well. Glacier has velcro tabs and that hold back the fingers not unlike the Simms mittens. You can still tie without taking them off, but line is going to catch if you leave the fingers folded back...
Based on a recommendation from a surf guy, I bought a bulk pack of Gorilla Grip work gloves, which are very thin. I tried them out yesterday on a warm day, and I would probably save my money (even though they were cheap) next time.
If you keep them dry, they can work in a pinch. But the whole point for surf fishing is that you constantly get wet, so these gloves retain their grip.
View attachment 1641234086