So I’ve been looking at some furled leaders for expermenting when I’m nymphing. One of the ones I’ve found is about 5-6’ of nylon which would attach to your fly line and then about 3’ of a high-visibility bi-color furled leader terminating at a tippet ring. It is advertised as a long line leader traditionally used for tight line tactics.
9' total length is on the short side for use as a tight-line leader. Even with 4-5ft of tippet added on during use it is still on the short side. I'd want to be starting with 15'+ of leader from fly line to tippet ring.
My questions are: has anyone had any experience with this?
Yes, but I did not see any real advantage over conventional mono leaders so I did not pursue it any further. The only real possibility is creating a super supple leader with tying thread... ...but there are disadvantages, and again I did not see enough advantage to continue experimenting with it. It's just easier to tie together a few sections of mono and sighter material.
And: wouldn’t the furled component have a difficult time staying tight to the line?
Depends. If the leader taper is designed to mimic a mono tight line leader this would not be a problem. If the leader is just a typical furled leader with a hi-vis section tacked on, then no, it probably won't perform as you would hope. It really depends on how much mass the leader has.
Thanks for any thoughts or suggestions.
Conventional tight line leaders have a big advantage in that they are not just easy to construct, but that you can modify any part of them in minutes while on the water. A furled leader is whatever taper and length that it started as and that is it. When you are just needing to add tippet, such as with a dry fly leader, that is usually fine. However, if you find that you need to add a different colored sighter, or longer sighter, or shorten/lengthen the leader butt section you are out of luck.
There are reasons to create hi-vis furled leaders, but tight lining ain't high on that list. Fish small dries, yep. Fishing flies just under the surface, yes again. As an alternative to mono tight line leaders.... ehhh.
It's one of those things that will work well enough that some people will take to it just to be different, not because it is better.