Fredrick wrote:
Tweed wrote: who said anything about Z-axis
Z-axis 8 wt weight about the same as the colton ....
What 8 wt do you have Tom a RPL ?
Well Fred since it casts like a Z buy it!
I have an RPL. I've had it going on 20 years and have caught more SMB, LMB, Steelies, Stripers, and yes, much to my dismay Carp with it than I can possibly remember. The rod has become an extension of my arm. And while at the time, it was one of the most expensive rods on the market ($300 +/- at the time), amortized over 20 years it was a bargain, IMO. Many guys I know have bought many rods in the last 20 years, and have never been truly satisfied with any of them. Which rod was the real bargain?
My only point is to choose carefully my friend. Checking out a website and deciding to buy the rod based on that is IMHO no the best way to chose a rod. Casting/fishing is an individual thing. One FFers treasure is another FFers trash. So the opinion of others on a rod may be useful in giving you an idea which rods to test, but the next step that I take is to cast a bunch in your price range including the Colton, and choose from there. What is the downside in checking out a bunch of rods? It’s actually a fun process to me. I would hate to see you looking for yet another SMB rod next year. The choice is yours.
Getting back to Colton. I don’t believe they are made in England. Hardy/Greys was the only manufacturer in England that I am aware of, and they now have their rods produced in Korea because of high labor costs in England. I cannot see a rod/blank at that price being made in England or the US. But no big deal though, some decent rods are made in the Far East.
As far as “fast” and cheap, I have not found a rod that is great fast action rod at a cheap price. For example TFO’s are a decent fast action rod, but they are very heavy for their rod weight. The less expensive rods use a lower modulus graphite and need thinker walls and a heavier butt to achieve a tip action rod. IMO, clunky best describes the feel in my hand.
There are many medium action rods out there that cast well, but faster rods are more expensive to build because of using high modulus graphite to keep weight down but make the rod durable. Check out the price of faster Sages, Winston, Scott, St. Croix, etc. They all are the most expensive rods in the line. I don’t think there’s collusion among rod manufacturers! I someone can build a light and fast rod for a modest price, it would be done. Like I said earlier, one FFers treasure is another ones trash when it comes to fly rods so my opinion is just…….my opinion.
Good luck on your search.