As a kid growing up in Warren during the 1950's, I guess I would have called the Conewango Creek my home water. I fished it extensively back then, often from the dam where it flows through town, as well as down to its confluence with the Allegheny a short distance downstream from there, and sometimes as far upstream as Russell. I won a couple fish contests for "most fish caught" off the Conewango Creek dam, and even had my picture in the PA Angler once showing off some walleyes I caught near the mouth one winter day while fishing with my uncle.
Although we moved from the area in the early 1960's, my wife's family owned a summer home on Chatauqua Lake through the 1980's, so we often drove along the Conewango from Warren to Jamestown, NY during those years, and a few times since.
However, although I remember catching a wide variety of fish there, including several trout, a musky or 2, walleyes, bass, and plenty of carp, I would never have thought of the Conewango as an award caliber creek/stream, and quite the contrary.
Anyone have any more up to date info on this award, or what might make the Conewango deserving of this "fame" today???
Thanks, John