Mike wrote:
Afish,
I understand your interpretation, but adding to the creel is not the driving force here. Rather, the intent is to get the fish out of the streams that get too warm for survival or reduce the fish populations to levels that more closely match the summer carrying capacity of the streams or their refuges. Adding to the creel is strictly the most effective mechanism to reduced the waste of fish that up until that point have served C&R anglers well. At some point however (fish dying from warm water temps and insufficient cold refuges) the waste factor kicks in. Some of this could be avoided in theory by reducing the stocking rate in spring to a rate that more closely matches the summer carrying capacity, but if that was done, the DH Areas would not be very popular.
I am not suggesting that individuals should harvest fish with no intent to eat them or share them with friends, but if achieving more harvest at the slow rate allowed by the creel limit and the low number of harvesting anglers still fishing after June 15 can only occur by opening the streams to harvest at an earlier date, I am all for it.