Akid-
I just tied 25 of a very similar pattern for the swap. What I used, and have used for this tie previously, is the Lightining Strike SE3 scud/emerger. It is 2X heavy, 2X short curved shank, 2Xwide, and continuous bend...what else could you ask for? Don't know how much of a difference all that makes, but it has been a good hook for me tying this pattern.