Beloved brown trout damage native fish, insects and waterways: Welcome to PA, New Zealand or Both?

Fish Sticks

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2022
Messages
3,194
City
Central PA
PA is pretty much just like New Zealand!!!!



In a classic study reported in 1991 and summarised by Jellyman, researchers looked at streams in Otago where waterfalls of at least 3 metres high were present. Waterfalls this size are barriers that browns can't get past.

Above the waterfalls, native galaxias fish were common and often thriving. Below the waterfalls, galaxias were "repeatedly absent". This was true regardless of the land-use beside the streams.

Citing more than 100 scientific papers, Jellyman and colleagues detail the "significant deleterious effects on native biodiversity" by brown trout.



“Jellyman and colleagues endorse a plea by other researchers for "increased restoration efforts to address impacts of trout on native fish and the seriously endangered galaxiid fauna".

“They also make a plea of their own.”

"Angling advocates have generally been at the forefront of efforts to maintain water quality, and have been justifiably quick to point out the positive effects of their efforts," they write. "Nevertheless, farmers, city dwellers and anglers must all accept responsibility and deal with all the problems they have created.

"As part of that, anglers need to accept that the brown trout‐based sports fishing resources, which are highly valued and woven into the fabric of New Zealand life, have had significant deleterious effects on native biodiversity."
 
IMG_4510.jpeg
 
PA is pretty much just like New Zealand!!!!

"Angling advocates have generally been at the forefront of efforts to maintain water quality, and have been justifiably quick to point out the positive effects of their efforts," they write. "Nevertheless, farmers, city dwellers and anglers must all accept responsibility and deal with all the problems they have created.
That pretty much sums up water and fish “conservation” in the United States.
 
Dear Fish Sticks,

Invasives species spread invasives species. That ain't exactly news!

If galaxias were to suddenly reclaim all of their former habitat invasive species would then travel elsewhere to spread invasive species.

IT'S SCIENCE!

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
 
Top